Why does the Colonel change his mind in a problem?

Why does the Colonel change his mind in a problem?

In “A Problem,” why does the Colonel change his mind about how to deal with Sasha? Ivan Markovitch recalls Sasha’s dead mother, saying that he thinks she is present and weeping for her son. Sasha promises to improve his behavior, which impresses the Colonel enough to change his mind.

What arguments does Ivan markovitch offer in Sasha’s defense?

In the story, Ivan Markovitch (Sasha’s maternal uncle) argues for leniency, while Sasha’s paternal uncle (the Colonel) argues for capital punishment as the only effective response to criminal conduct.

Who is the Colonel in a problem by Anton Chekhov?

Definition Example
Dynamic Character Undergoes important changes during the story. Ivan
Static Character Does not go through important changes during the story. Sasha, Colonel
Character Motivation Character’s reason to act Ivan: acting out of good will and care for family Sasha: greed

What request does Sasha make of Ivan at the end of the story?

What request does Sasha make of Ivan Markovitch at the end of the story? He demands for 100 roubles so that he could go party.

Why does the Colonel change his mind about dealing with Sasha?

Why does the Colonel change his mind about how to deal with Sasha? Ivan Markovitch recalls Sasha’s dead mother, saying that he thinks she is preset and weeping for her son. Sasha promises to improve his behavior, which impresses the Colonel enough to change him mind.

What does the colonel think should happen to Sasha?

What does the Colonel think should be done about Sasha? Why? He thinks Sasha should be punished for his crimes, because he believes that Sasha will continue his bad behavior if they don’t stop him.

How does Uncle Ivan convince the other?

How does Uncle Ivan convince the other uncles to help Sasha? He reminds them that Sasha is young, uneducated, and an orphan. How does Uncle Ivan’s attitude in “A Problem” harm Sasha? It enables Sasha to continue his irresponsible ways.

Who is the Colonel in relation to Sasha?

Sasha’s other uncle is a Colonel. He does not want to pay off Sasha’s debt and wants him to go to trial. The colonel is set on doing what he thinks is honorable and letting Sasha go to trial.

How has Sasha changed in the course of the story?

When Sasha finds out that he is to go scot-free for his crime, he physically intimidates Markovitch into lending him a hundred roubles. Sasha has now progressed from being sullenly apathetic to being overtly contemptuous of the misplaced mercy that would spare him the rightful consequences for his actions.

What is Chekhov’s tone towards Sasha?

What do you think Chekhov’s attitude is toward Sasha? Is his tone judgmental, compassionate, or sarcastic? He does not coddle the idea of what sasha did, and shows us the sarcasm in the mistakes he has previously made.

Why is Sasha in trouble quizlet?

Why was Sasha in trouble? Sasha was in trouble because he cashed a false promissory note.

How do you think Ivan markovitch feels at the end of the story?

He feels free and wants to party with his friends. He regrets the trouble that he has caused his family. How does Ivan Markovitch feel at the end of “A Problem,” and why? He realizes that his friends are all criminals, so he thinks he must be one too.

Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. Press ESC to cancel.

Back To Top