Table of Contents
- 1 What reason does Holden give for not going downstairs to see Jane?
- 2 Why do you think Holden doesn’t go to say hi to Jane even though he repeatedly says he wants to?
- 3 Why does Holden feel sad when he thinks about the gift his mother gave him?
- 4 What made Holden not depressed anymore?
- 5 What do Holden and the cab driver talk about?
- 6 Why is Holden not too crazy about describing rooms and houses?
- 7 Why did Holden not confront Jane in the catcher in the Rye?
- 8 Why is Stradlater troubling in the catcher in the Rye?
What reason does Holden give for not going downstairs to see Jane?
Stradlater had a date with her. Why doesn’t Holden go down to see Jane? He wasn’t “in the mood.”
Why do you think Holden doesn’t go to say hi to Jane even though he repeatedly says he wants to?
Why do you think Holden doesn’t go down to say hi to Jane? I think Holden is worried about intimacy, he doesn’t know how to handle it. At the same time he can’t stomach Jane seeing anyone else, especially Stradlater.
Why does Holden not want to talk to Jane?
Holden is nervous about his going out with Jane because of Stradlater’s sexual experience. He does not want Stradlater to make a move on Jane because he fancies her for himself (despite being too awkward to do anything about it).
Why does Holden decide to walk to the park and what terrible event happens there?
He was drunk, and according to him, he’s a madman while drunk. Why does Holden decide to walk to the park, and what “terrible” event happens there? He walks in the park to see where the ducks are and he drops Sophie’s record and it shatters into 50 pieces.
Why does Holden feel sad when he thinks about the gift his mother gave him?
Holden says that he needs an operation because he has a small brain tumor. Why does packing his ice skates make Holden feel sad? Holden reflects that his mother bought him this thoughtful gift, and he is disappointing her again by being expelled. Every time someone gives him a gift, it ends up making him sad.
What made Holden not depressed anymore?
Holden then mentions that the boy singing makes him feel better and less depressed about life. In any case, hearing the boy sing makes Holden feel a little less depressed. The words of the song conjure up an image of Holden standing on the edge of a cliff.
How is money often a trigger for Holden’s depression?
How is money often a trigger for Holden’s depression? Money makes other people angry and Holden will always have problems in life as long as he has money, also it makes Holden angry when other people do not have money or nice things. Money is the main factor for Holden’s depression.
What was Holden going to say to get to talk to Jane?
Expert Answers Holden keeps saying he is going to call Jane Gallagher , a girl who used to “practically (live) next door to (him), the summer before last” (Chapter 4).
What do Holden and the cab driver talk about?
During one of Holden’s cab rides in the city, he carries on a conversation with a taxi driver named Horwitz about where the ducks in the Central Park lagoon go in the winter. Holden wonders whether someone in a truck picks them up or if they actually fly south for the winter like he’s been taught.
Why is Holden not too crazy about describing rooms and houses?
Why is Holden “not too crazy about describing rooms and houses” (49)? He couldn’t imagine what Stradlater had said to describe. This could be because he changes schools so much, he never has a consecutive home or place to describe.
Why does Holden not go into the museum?
When he actually gets to the museum, he decides not to go in; that would require disturbing his fragile imaginative construction by making it encounter the real world. He wants life to remain frozen like the display cases in the museum.
Why is Holden nervous about Stradlater and Jane having sex?
Holden is nervous because he doesn’t want Stradlater and Jane to have sex. After all, Holden has romantic feelings for Jane, so he doesn’t want his roommate to engage in any romantic activity with her. At the same time, though, Holden’s feelings for Jane aren’t strictly romantic—they also have to do with the way he idealizes childhood.
Why did Holden not confront Jane in the catcher in the Rye?
Even though Holden clearly feels fondly about Jane, he can’t bring himself to actually confront her. This is because he has idealized her in his mind. As a result, actually meeting her would threaten to destroy the perfect version of her that he has built for himself.
Why is Stradlater troubling in the catcher in the Rye?
Looking back, he remembers the time he spent with Jane as happy and untroubled, a part of his past for which he feels quite nostalgic. The idea of Stradlater having sex with Jane, then, is especially troubling because it shatters his ability to think about Jane in an innocent way and thus disrupts his idealized childhood memories.
Why does Holden put Stradlater in a half nelson?
Because he thinks it’s good for people like Stradlater to experience a bit of suspense in their lives, though, Holden doesn’t answer right away, instead asking whom Stradlater is dating. When Stradlater doesn’t immediately tell him, Holden jumps up and puts him in a half-nelson, taking him by surprise and momentarily infuriating him.